I've just watched a very interesting docu on Dave about dog meat in Korea, and I must admit it changed my views somewhat, so I thought I'd share.
Dogs there can be considered in a similar way to pigs here, we eat some pigs farmed for the purpose, but we also keep some pigs as pets, and we wouldn't eat those ones, but MIGHT still eat bacon.
The western intolerance of all dogs as meat means Korea will not legislate about it as that would mean they would have to take a side against their own people, which means many cruel farming techniques continue uncontrolled, as they don't see why they should ban it just 'cos westerners don't like it, but if they did officially legalise and control it without banning it then the west would see that as an endorsement and get all animal rightsy on them, so instead they just ignore it completely.
It's an interesting example of cultural clash and indeed bleeding heart western idealism, causing more problems than if we all just left other countries to sort their own problems out their own way.
Anyhoo, surprisingly, you can also order it online and get it delivered, oh, and 'Kittybeef' too, which is a whole other issue I'm not going into.
Make of that what you will...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:23, Reply)
I have a friend who will not eat meat from a butchers because he sees a bloke handling and chopping it up as 'dirty', he'll only eat it bought in supermarkets in nice clean looking polystyrene trays.
We are going a bit weird on this issue over here when you think about it.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:48, Reply)
They waste tons of food because they are looking for, say apples, which are the same size, shape, and shininess. And if you buy pork chops now, they are all the same size, packs are the same weight. Even the missus would rather buy a bag of apples, all the same size, than rather go to a grocer (a rare sight, I know) and pick what she would prefer. The long and the short of it is that we live in a society where things have to look good for us to buy...
I shall stop, getting a bit sad now...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:57, Reply)
but they then threw away about a third of what they'd farmed during packaging, 'cos it wasn't a uniform size or bent to one side a bit.
Mad...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:08, Reply)
www.walkersfarmmarket.com/images/asparagus_field.jpg
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:35, Reply)
and if you cut a stem at a too early stage you can kill the root base.
The expense is mainly the labour-intensive crop picking as the pickers need to be trained how and when to cut.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:43, Reply)
how he thinkgs the meat gets put into the packaging in the 1st place?
Or how much chance meat has of getting "dirty" by being handled by someone on a production line, barely qualified, working for piss all money and probably hating his shitty life draining job copmapred to a meat specialist who has chosen to dedicate thier life to preparing meat? Or how the local business butcher has to be alot more careful about health and safety rules compared to a mindless coporate drone?
Basicly, you;ve got a better chance of getting a cleamer bit of meat from a butcher than a supoermarket and you'll probably get a better cut too.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:07, Reply)
He also throws everything that meets or passes the use by date immediately. Oh, and buys bread on the fact of just how 'light and fluffy' it is and freeks out at home-made bread as 'heavy and chewy', and refuses to eat fresh veg his dad grows in his allotment 'cos it's been in soil and pig muck and absolutely will not eat anything with an eye such as whole prawns, pre-prepared tails only, same with fish, he'll look at a whole one with absolute disgust.
I could go on. And on...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:15, Reply)
makes me think of that HFW thing about battery chickens.
He did a taste test with a normal chicken and a battery one and he got almost equal results.
People who prefered the battery chicken said it was because it was more bland.
People who prefered the normal chicken said it had more taste.
Anyways. look up some "how they make supermarket food" vids and see if you can't change his mind.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:28, Reply)
but I do try and get something that's actually FOOD, not some over processed shite that's basically oil, starch and sugar chemically altered and reformed to look and taste like it is, but cost is always an issue, so I have to find a middle ground (I always get free range eggs for example but I can't be as choosy on the chicken meat, I just try and find the least processed for my health).
Not a bad idea on the vids tho, he'll never eat again, LOL!
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:37, Reply)
can u punch the fucker for me please
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:08, Reply)
I have started getting to him to read ingredients rather than just trust the 'healthy option' labels on factory prepped meals tho, so he's learning a bit.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:17, Reply)
And lick every pea individually for taste.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:24, Reply)
I told him white english mushrooms are grown in steamed pig manure (I know this 'cos I have done this job) and he didn't eat them for weeks!
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:25, Reply)
Oh and that's another thing, he prepares mashed potato by using a mixer so it has the same consistency as packet!
*shakes head*
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:33, Reply)
It's true, that's what that black line is. A gut full of shit.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 12:16, Reply)
How's it any different to sheep/pig/cow?
(I've never had a pet dog, so that might have something to do with it)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:33, Reply)
But would try dog. I would eat a pet pig though. Strange eh!
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:37, Reply)
mostly it's 'cos in the west we see certain animals as sharing our family life and being on an equal footing as people, as 'friends'. Koreans and many other countries (according to this docu I saw) see us as having gone too far down this route and being somewhat mad (like we do things like kill people to save animals!)
And TBH I'm kinda on their side about that last one.
I have to say I still wouldn't eat dog or cat, BUT I think other countries who do should be left alone to legislate upon it as they see fit.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:42, Reply)
The fact of the matter is that it was a very common meat in the UK during the wars.
At the end of the day, people constantly try to anthropomorphise animals. It is something that has gone on for thousands of years, you only have to look at the Ancient Egyptians to see that.
People, as they spend time with Dogs and Cats more commonly than they do Pigs or Cows, actually get to know the personalities of those animals. As they don't get to know the personalities of Cows and Sheep and Pigs as commonly, they are able to convince themselves that they have no personalities.
It is a typical Western arrogance that our culture is more valid than any other culture, and thus we stick out noses up at countries like Korea and such.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:58, Reply)
anthropomorfi... anthropopoppopmorphi.... that word up
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:57, Reply)
And I've eaten that before (not them!), but I was pretty old when she got them, 15 or so. I guess if you grow up with a certain species from a young age (unless you live on a farm) you're going to bond with and anthropomorphise that species, making it harder to eat it later on.
I remember catching an episode of The Hairy Bikers when they were in Korea. They'd agreed they wouldn't eat dog, and took great pains to avoid it. Towards the end of the episode they were tucking into a hearty meal when they realised just what they were eating, at which point they couldn't eat any more. Naturally if they discovered they were eating human meat it'd be understandable to go nuts, but their reaction seemed a bit over the top considering they'd misidentified a type of animal.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 12:23, Reply)
as a kid it was standard for stews and casseroles, co op butchers used to do it as a carcass,or cuts. You have to be well out of cities to see it in a butchers now.
There are few things I can`t face, from time in africa on a job crocodile Is one,fishy chicken flavoured connective tissue. I`ve tried zebra, lovely and hartebeeste ( farmed freerange ) so?
No-one ever believes me at first unless they go to a definitive paper source, as it sometimes hides online to google, but guinea pigs were introduced to europe as food animals to supplant/supplement rabbits as they grew fast and were tasty
Its all meat and living to start with.
It`s like vegaetarians who eat fish, "ah but i can`t hear it scream and it isn`t aesthetically pleasing"
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:02, Reply)
it is still available fairly widely.
Also, Guinea Pigs yes, you're right. Growing up we had a lot of guinea pigs. When one of them died we were talking to a friends mum, who is from Peru, and she gave us a recipe for Guinea Pig. We never used it, but in South America it is terribly common by all accounts.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:18, Reply)
have to say tho I never really liked either, or duck, they're all a bit gamey and stringy for me.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:19, Reply)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:38, Reply)
A few weeks ago I ate a chicken's foot by mistake :(
I'm usually not too bothered by the species of the animal as long as it's been raised in a manner I deem ethical. Seems a bit hypocritical when people complain about [unusual animal] being eaten while almost every native British animal could be seen as some form of delicacy.
How about you?
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:43, Reply)
I'd love to bang on about welfare, but wont. Its the conditioning that british people are brought up with. Cows go moo and taste of beef. Dogs are 'mans best friend'. It a whole issue fraught with irrationality which I would love to get into, but I have to go to work;-)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:49, Reply)
I don't understand why more people don't keep away from lamb. People are, as you say, conditioned from a very early age to think "Awwwww, it's so cute, I love lambs and wish them no harm".
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:54, Reply)
I am a bit soft like that, brought up on a farm tho, playing with (very intelligent) pigs, so you can imagine I get confused at times...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:57, Reply)
it is your ability to humanise animals that forbids you to eat them ;-)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:00, Reply)
they could be taught tricks, they could recognise you and their name, they all had diffrent personalities and could be very affectionate, they love having belly rubs.
And then one day he'd be on my plate.
But as a kid this was normal and I just accepted it.
As an aside, I was the only kid at my new school in Selby that had zero reaction to the tetanus shot and have no scar to prove it BTW.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:24, Reply)
if we weren't poking our noses in they could do something about that.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:44, Reply)
Without pressure, I can't see them voluntarily regulating the industry. It's somewhat of a taboo subject engaged in mostly by the very poor.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:46, Reply)
and weirdly it's becoming a delicacy in some parts (those considered 'posh') due to such pressure pushing it into a rarer found practise and therefore pushing up the price.
Kinda like frog legs and snails in France I guess, and I dare say we have equivalents, wasn't caviar once a poor man's food?
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:54, Reply)
I suppose it's a really big shameful mess that can only go away when Korean social norms slowly adjust to view it as an unacceptable thing to do (i.e. inhumane rearing).
Looks like your post has stimulated some interesting debate which is always great to see.
:)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 9:59, Reply)
and even speaking as a kid on a farm, if the pet rabbit died you wouldn't cook it.
Besides, if it dies of old age, it'll taste awful and be terribly tough! ;)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:31, Reply)
cheers!
*edit* also just fancied an interesting natter... ;)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:28, Reply)
Edit should that be:how much is that doggy under Windows?
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:25, Reply)
terrible, will not eat again.
*edit* Oh, and I had sea cucumber soup once and only later found out it is RAW! They just chop off the head and take the guts out and slice it, the heat of the soup is all the cooking it gets.
You know when you make gravy and the gravy powder sometimes stays in semi-solid slimy chunks? That was sea cucumber, but without the taste.
Curious about ostrich tho!
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:40, Reply)
I have only had it in burger form, but it is quite tasty.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:46, Reply)
ie. not fatty and chem filled.
Would be willing to try, how does it taste? Like beefy chicken I have in my head (dunno why...)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:54, Reply)
It is quite hard to describe. I'd hate to say 'like chicken' as most things seem to when being described. Has a certain quality about it. Dry, but not too dry, as it is quite lean meat, and not very fatty. They usually are quite thick and hold the shape well. The best thing to do is try it. It doesn't taste of anything extra ordinary ;-)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:04, Reply)
I thought it was quite beefy, but lean. I'll have it again sometime.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:44, Reply)
it was very greasy. but quite tasty.
The agin i lived in Japan and ate whale. Which was also quite blubbery.
Both were nice though and i'd happily have them again.
I think all animal farming is cruel. Watching a gracious blue whale being dragged bleeding through the ocean ready for slaughter is enough to bring anyone to tears.
But so is seeing a baby pig stabbed in the face with an electric de-pigging device at a western abattoir.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 10:59, Reply)
but not many put 2 and 2 together and realise this means the small rashers you end up with after a good grilling must have come from VERY young pigs.
REALLY not sure I could eat whale, tho have had shark so I dunno really...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:04, Reply)
I doubt bonsai trees are happy with their lot in life either but plenty of people still have them
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:40, Reply)
i think i prefer eating hunted stuff.
farming stuff seems unnatural.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:46, Reply)
swings n roundabouts...
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:54, Reply)
there aren't many places in the world where you can still live like that anymore though
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 12:08, Reply)
he's retired but has farmer friends who semi-employ him to keep down the wild life (pigeons, feral cats, rats, rabbits etc) and a lot of it could be eaten quite happily, but few folks actually would if he gave it to them, altho he's said some of the farm hands have taken the rabbits off him (they live 'off the grid' in caravans attached via cable and pipe to the farms electricity and gas and for labour on the farm they get to eat and live for free, not a bad deal).
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 12:20, Reply)
scorpions
crocodile
kangaroo
rat (I didn't know until someone told me afterwards)
snake blood in rice whisky
there's plenty i'll try, but my experience is that the more commonly farmed animals are the tastier, healthier ones to eat.
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:11, Reply)
That if she's bad we'll make some Schnauzer Schnitzel out of her.
And she just looks up at us with those big trusting brown eyes, wagging her tail...
Actually, 'Schnauzer Schnitzel' is a cracking brand name, might have to go register it ;o)
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:33, Reply)
Heck, we got hot dogs, this could just be a brand name!
(, Thu 18 Jun 2009, 11:36, Reply)
