By the time her kid is 18 she will be 91. The 1st act as an adult your child is going to take is to put you in a home.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 8:27, Reply)
she dedicated her life to her career and furthering her knowledge rather than just fucking from 16 years old and living on the state.
Sorry but surely these are the kinds of people that we want breeding? A little earlier would of been better of course but still, you can't choose your family, and there are kids with far worse chances out there with parents much younger.
Just my 2 pence worth.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:08, Reply)
Maybe before the kid reaches 18. Before she dies, will she be strong enough to support the thing? It would need quite a caring wider family to do all the things for it a child needs.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:30, Reply)
But it's possible to be a very healthy 91-year-old, and not so long ago there would have been a reasonable chance that mothers died diring their children's early years anyway - so the historical precedent of having unwell or dead mothers seems to suggest that things'll be OK.
Moreover, whatever happens, it's almost a cert that the child will have a life worth living - it's not as if it'll have been better off never having been born - so, on that basis, there doesn't seem to be much of a problem.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:52, Reply)
and I suppose we can say that it's preferable for the child to live rather than not (although it's not like it's a definite; there is no child yet so it can't have a concept of it's own existence so it wouldn't really mind not being born, so to speak).
But the act smacks of self-indulgence - she really isn't likely to be in peak condition to be giving birth. It's perfectly possible for her to become a 91-year old, and she could probably beat me in an arm wrestle, but then again...in ten years' time, who will be wiping whose arse? She's likely to need more care as the child becomes more independent. I can't imagine the raging hormones of a fourteen year old dealing with an 87-yearl old mum - 'you don't understand me!' 'Of course I don't, I was born 87 years ago to an entirely different world.'
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:06, Reply)
Hell, if you want to be cynical about it, having kids because you want them at all is self-indulgent. By this standard, it's only accidental pregnancies that are OK... which is absurd.
As for the understanding part - I simply don't see it. Most people understand most other people. And, even if they don't, where's the harm?
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:17, Reply)
OK, most pregnancies are self-indulgent, but they're done with more consideration for the child. I'm not going to be able to back this up with facts and figures - I'm not sure they would exist - but if someone decides to have a child, I'd bet they consider (for example) their financial situation, their health, their ability to protect the child, their ability to raise the child effectively.
Whilst this lady may be good at all those things, there's a higher than normal chance she won't be good at all those things. She won't be giving birth, if she does conceive, in the best possible situation for the child - hence me thinking there's a tad more self-indulgence at play than normal.
It's going to be difficult to take this further without knowing the circumstances she's in, so speculation may be king from here, but why didn't she have a child earlier in life? Why has she decided that now is a good time, and not even just ten years ago? Is she going to raise the child with a decent support network? How physically healthy is she? Again, these points are applicable for younger parents too - but the main point is that she's doing this at a time in her life when things are more likely to be bad for the child (if she dies, becomes unhealthy etc).
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:28, Reply)
What's to say that the woman in this story hasn't carefully worked things out - more carefully than most?
Of course, she won't be giving birth in the best possible circumstances. However, that doesn't tell us that she shouldn't be giving birth at all. After all, there's no woman who's ever given birth in the best possible circumstances.
And if she is self-indulgent, and is measurably more so than other mothers, and if that is, somehow, deeply problematic... well, again, it tells us a little about her, but nothing at all about her pregnancy. If you're going to avoid double standards, you would seem to have to say that all women having IVF should go through a process of screening to ensure that they don't have character flaws. Again, that'd be absurd.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:45, Reply)
I was saying these were the reasons why she might not choose to give birth. (I'd also add in the 'eeeww!' factor of imagining the birth video.)
That she's choosing to go through this - the stress, the worry, the physical hardship, the commitment and the uncertainty - when she's beyond the age whereby such things would be commonplace, expected or predicted (or possible, up until recently) in order to have a baby seems odd to me personally, and maybe suggests to me she might be a bit of a nutter (if I may put it indelicately).
She's free to do what she wants - fire them out for the next twenty years, if she lives that long - but it seems like a rum business to me.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:08, Reply)
Isn't the whole of medicine about getting around what we might otherwise expect or predict?
If someone's eyes dim due to age, and we can reverse it or avoid the consequences, we consider that a good thing. If their hearing fades, the same applies. Ditto all manner of other things. Why should reversing the effects of time on the reproductive system be all that different?
Aren't they all aspects of a cure for old age?
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:11, Reply)
but that doesn't mean that old people are automatically fit and healthy. Perhaps one day, but a 72 year old giving birth will still be more at risk of complications than a younger mother. And the risk of birth defects will still be much higher.
Like I said, I don't object to it in theory...but it seems rum for the reasons we've talked about (you've made me consider them an awful lot, so thank you for that, but I'm not sure you've changed my mind yet...)
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:18, Reply)
Even granted a higher-than-average risk of birth defects, relatively few of them are so awful that it would be better not to have been born - so relatively few will give the child grounds to complain about it.
:)
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:46, Reply)
How can we say existence is preferable to non-existence, for the thing that wouldn't exist and so wouldn't know it didn't exist so wouldn't have an opinion on the matter?
There are lots of things that don't exist - we can't say if it's better or not that they don't exist, and they definitely can't.
If we're assuming that all life is good, and all existence is good (and preferable to non-existence), does it not follow that the suitable comparison/reference point/benchmark is things that exist? In which case, we say Jock McScroty lived an awful life, not as good as William T McRichandcleverman, but we can't say for certain that Mr McScroty would have been better off never having existed at all? But from the point of view of Mr McRichandcleverman, Mr McScroty's life was not worth it.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 12:15, Reply)
I ended up doing some work.
The test is whether a life is burdensome. Presumably, there could be at least some conditions that'd mean that it's better not to be alive (and people reach that kind of decision all the time). Presumably, too, there are conditions that might be so appalling that, whatever good points there are in a life, it would still turn out to have been better not to have lived it at all. (That is: we can imagine a welfare scale between 1 and -1, where zero represents nothing good or bad. Most lives will have a positive welfare score - they'll be worth living - but some might have a negative one. Death, being the absence of any sensation, scores zero by default - and therefore might be better than certain terrible lives. Not existing at all would also be zero, so might also be better than certain (potential) lives.)
Now, if you could reasonably predict that a new life would be that burdensome, then it might well be better for that life never to be lived, since there'll be less unnecessary suffering that way. Welfare score of zero rather than minus-something.) However, the point remains that there are very few lives that are so terrible - and so predictably terrible - that it is better for them never to begin.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 13:05, Reply)
Until she says 'a parent can die at any age - look at Jade Goody'. Surely an academic would understand the concept of probability factoring in to such a statement? And why the Goody namecheck?
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:32, Reply)
tugs at all the heart strings of the fucks that think that she shouldn't be having a kid in the first place. Possibly...
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:40, Reply)
the fact remains that she is too old. If she manages to have a child, what kind of childhood would she be able to provide?
Her chances of dying before her child reaches maturity is alot higher than average.
The chances that she will need help adn support to raise her child and then have to enlist her child to help adn support her are very high.
If only she had had children when she was alot younger.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:39, Reply)
it's like saying that a 15/16 year old parent is going to give a child a good start in life. They aren't, it's just as bad (if not worse), the first years of anyones life are the most important, up to teenage years when they start making decisions for themselves. Although it's all very nice and rosey having parents to the ages of 30/40+, it isn't essential.
I'd rather see an academic pensioner raise a child to 18 than an adolescent dole scrounger raise a child to 10 and have child support remove them for not being bothered to look after them, just for that child to go and do exactly the same thing.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:45, Reply)
...16 year olds aren't considered to be mature enough to make a positive contribution to their child's development, to teach, to nurture - so we tend not to encourage it.
A 73 year old parent is likely to have downsides too - lack of relative physical strength being the main one. High chance of death. High chance of injury. High chance of ridicule from other kids at school.
So while it's not necessary being in your 30s, it is preferable.
I take your point about nobheads having kids at all ages, but one unsuitable parent isn't an excuse to allow another one.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:57, Reply)
...just 'higher' than someone aged in their 30s.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 9:58, Reply)
... yes, they're there. But the important question concerns whether they're sufficient to tell us anything about the propriety of having a child. Frankly, I don't think that they count for all that much: the child wouldn't suffer (given that the comparator is never coming to exist at all).
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:01, Reply)
and the child wouldn't suffer from that, either.
She may well make an excellent parent; then again, she may teach the child racist views from the 50s and sit there drooling while leaving the thing to starve in the corner.
It's the increased risk of these negative aspects that rankles; if she was having a child for the child's benefit, she would've done it four decades ago to produce optimum conditions, so it seems like she's accepting these possible negatives that the child, not her, will have to deal with to satisfy her own cravings.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:11, Reply)
That doesn't make sense. It's not as if there's a holding-pen of pre-embryos checking their watches and demanding that someone get round to bringing them to birth.
See my answer above for a response to the cravings point. It doesn't stack up either.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:20, Reply)
so we can't say that this child will have a better life being born than not being born. The thing doesn'tt exist, so we can't say that the life it will have is better than otherwise. It's not like if if doesn't get born to her, it'll get born to someone else...it would just never exist.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:32, Reply)
So, if the child is born, it'll increase the level of net welfare in the world (almost inevitably - leave aside the small possibility of a life so blighted that it's not worth living).
In other words, a world with the child is a better world than one without. Therefore, if we're concerned to maximise welfare, we ought to welcome (if not encourage) the pregnancy.
/Derek Parfit blog.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:53, Reply)
Would it have that much impact?
Or would we need a sustainable campaign to see this benefit of welfare increase? A sort-of 'IVF For All!'?
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:56, Reply)
If it's welfare concerns that fuel your objections, though - and that does seem to be the case - then the point would stand that it's at least possible that you should be advocating IVF for all.
It's a slightly diluted version of what Parfit calls "the repugnant conclusion" - essentially, that if you think that welfare is the most important consideration in moral decisionmaking, and given that a world with many people living just-about bearable lives could well be better than one with many fewer people living slightly better lives, then it looks like we ought to go for the highly populated and more miserable world.
Parfit doesn't like the conclusion, but admits that it's one that he can't easily avoid given his other claims about welfare, identity and so on.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:03, Reply)
The welfare concern isn't really a factor in my thoughts at all, outside of the individual welfare of the child (so not on a grand scale).
How is Parfitt defininf 'welfare' when he talks about it being the most important consideration in a moral decision? Socially, personally, economically...?
Why does he believe that world a, with more people could well be better than world b, with it's seemingly higher living standards?
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:13, Reply)
The argument'd still work formally.
I can't remember exactly how the argument works, but it's encapsulated here:
The Repugnant Conclusion: For any possibile populaiton of at least ten billion people, all with a very high quality of life, there must be some much larger imaginable population whose existence, if other things are equal, would be better, even though its members have lives that are barely worth living.
See Reasons and Persons secs 131, but also 146-7. Actually, the whole thing. It's a deceptively difficult book - I don't claim nearly to have taken a lot of it in - but very rewarding if you stick with it...
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 11:23, Reply)
kids take the piss out of anyone and anything.
And I still don't agree that a 16 year old can raise a child particularly well. My brother has worked in the child care sector for a good few years now and has to deal with the abandoned children whos chavvy adolescent parents just gave up on them, these kids *dont* get addopted. I've heard quite enough nasty tales that have made my mind up there.
On the other hand, let's say she gets to 13 before her parent dies. Being raised by someone with obviously higher life experience and presumably high morals, as well as a strong academic background would make them far more likely to be adopted than some 16 year olds crack child.
Quality, not quantity. And anyway, what do you know of this ladies state of health? Not everyone is a complete and utter wreck at 70.
(, Wed 15 Jul 2009, 10:10, Reply)