You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 341440 | Random

This is a link post Huxley Vs. Orwell
An interesting comparison between the two authors in cartoon form
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 1:31, Reply)
This is a normal post Very, very good.
thanks
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 3:37, Reply)
This is a normal post That's fantastic...
and genuinely very well argued and drawn.
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 9:10, Reply)
This is a normal post Excellent
Though the artist (or Neil Postman) seems to reject Orwell's position out of hand a little too readily. Can't these two visions of dytopia just get along?

(Like the pointed irony of having the Big Brother compound featured on Huxley's side)
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 10:04, Reply)
This is a normal post Orwell was a much better writer than Huxley
who came up with fantastic concepts encoded into catchy phrases. Some would call them memes. Newspeak, Big Brother, Room 101, Doublethink etc. Orwell has enriched our language hugely.

But the cartoon is making a fair point - there's ideas in Huxley's work that are prescient, but I'd still much rather read Orwell.
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 11:03, Reply)
This is a normal post Ditto
The difference in predictive world view and outlook is largely a product of their times though - Brave New World is written in 1931 which is far more similar socially to our time that '49 when Ninteen Eighty Four was written. Orwell's work is steeped in fears of Communist-style takeovers and is shaped by the emerging Cold War, whereas in a carefree consumerist world where technology and medicine is developing rapidly allowing preoccupations of the day to look like they might become reality (ie, Eugenics) has many more mirrors with our own post-cold war mentality...
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 11:30, Reply)
This is a normal post Despite my above comment, agreed.
Orwell a superb writer (my fav is Burmese Days), but I don't think it's too controversial to suggest he also had some, ahem, mental issues which made him a little paranoid, depressed and the like, and therefore often prone to alarmist views. Arguably, a bit of this is often associated with creative genius.
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 11:48, Reply)
This is a normal post I enjoyed this very much
A good point well put.
(, Thu 16 Jul 2009, 14:48, Reply)