Lord of the Rings
Most of the casting was spot-on, but Arwen was a horrible misfire. Liv Tyler's fine in the role but, and I know the film isn't slavishly faithful to the book, I'm pretty sure it's a pivotal part of Arwen's character that she's staggeringly hot. If I'd been Aragorn I'd have told her to bog off and shagged Eowyn.
(Darth Foxtrot A one-man army dedicated to making fetch happen, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:53, 3 replies, latest was 16 years ago)

^this
I can never conclusively decide whether Liv Tyler's that attractive - particularly as she seems to be developing her father's huge mouth. Miranda Otto, on the other hand, is a definite would.
(LongJohnBaldry, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:55, Reply)

I agree with this unequivocally
My main problem with Liv Tyler is that she's her father's daughter, and Steven Tyler is not only responsible for some of the most vacuous, turgid rock music ever produced, but an annoying cunt to boot
(Darth Foxtrot A one-man army dedicated to making fetch happen, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:57, Reply)

Aerosmith were far better before they cleaned up

(LongJohnBaldry, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 12:09, Reply)

Her huge mouth would be excellent for my huge cock*

*may contain traces of QOTW style lies
( Naked Ape call me Caitlyn, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:58, Reply)

Yeah, her mouth isn't that big
...what?
( Agnostic Antichrist Baltimora, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:59, Reply)

she seems to have a stupid lisp in that as well
which is annoying
( Vipros. clever got me this far, then tricky got me in, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:57, Reply)

She just looks sort of drippy and lifeless.
Generally a bit pathetic really.
(Applebite Uh! A cow!, Wed 31 Mar 2010, 11:59, Reply)