You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Talk » Message 8492906 (Thread)

Morning Lu.
I read Dune when I was 16 and then again about a year ago, and definitely got a different experience from it. The themes made a lot more sense as an adult, whereas when I was a teenager I didn’t really grasp that it’s not a hero’s story, it’s a morally grey story about difficult choices, utilitarianism and tripping balls.

However, my favourite book is Shogun, which I just finished re-reading for about the sixth or seventh time. It doesn’t really change on revisiting, but it’s long enough that every time I go back to it there’s a bit I'd completely forgotten.

Or hedge porn, lol.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:40, Reply)
Good morning! Ooh that’s two more I haven’t read.
Dune sounds right up my street. Never even heard of Shogun so I’ll look it up after I’ve had a bath.
If you like Dune (and I’m only going on what you just said about it) you may like Doris Lessing - Memoirs of a Survivor.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:45, Reply)
Just looked your recommendation up, and it sounds interesting.
I have a few books I want to get through but I can definitely add some dystopian feminist sci-fi to my backlog, thanks.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:53, Reply)
Wait you wanted to know why it’s my favourite.
I’m not even sure why. It’s a well-written fish-out-of-water tale set in Japan in 1600. An English guy ends up there by accident and gets drawn into the politics of the imminent war. It has themes of death, deceit and self-reflection. And it has samurai and ninjas, which are cool.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:47, Reply)
Have you read the others?

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:04, Reply)
Most of them.
I’m actually working through Gai-Jin for the first time at the moment. It’s ok. I’ve read Tai-Pan, Noble House and King Rat. That only leaves Whirlwind. Have you?
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:17, Reply)
Years ago.

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:41, Reply)
I have added it to my list.
Not sure it’s definitely my kind of thing but I don’t know until I make the effort.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:05, Reply)
It has a surprising number of references to the relative sizes of European and Japanese penises.

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:30, Reply)
b3ta, you mean

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:43, Reply)
Yep, something for everyone to enjoy there.

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 12:11, Reply)
ever read this?
www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B005QE4H7M/?th=1
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:42, Reply)
That looks very good.
It reminded me of this, entirely unrelated and just took me a bloody long time to hunt down because I couldn’t remember the title, or author. Because I have a goldfish brain. amzn.eu/d/05ZcYENd
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:55, Reply)
that looks excellent, as is this
www.amazon.co.uk/Salt-World-History-Kurlansky-2003-03-06/dp/B0182Q3JNS/?th=1
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:42, Reply)
Well he seems to know his salt.
And milk, apparently. amzn.eu/d/08soIth3
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:51, Reply)
No but I think I should.
I knew Shogun was very loosely based on a true story, and that appears to be it.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:57, Reply)
yep, correct
it's a great read, especially for a Shogun fan. Love the Richard Chamberlain TV adaptation too. It was the most expensive tv programme ever made at the time. The 'making of' extras in the DVD box set are insane. Plus it's got Toshiro Mifune in it, as well as Pigsy from Monkey.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:42, Reply)
Thanks Queef, I'll check it out.
The Richard Chamberlain TV version was great, and so was the recent one (last year or whenever).
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 12:13, Reply)
I think Dune's a fantastic book, I had pretty much the same experience with it, really enjoyed it as a kid but didn't fully get it

(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 13:14, Reply)