... but please, please, please take a couple of minutes to read this statement and then to sign the petition therewith.
For the sake of clarification: this is not about putting the boot into the British Chiropractic Association. It’s about preventing the BCA - or anyone else - putting the boot into people who publicly and in good faith dispute their scientific claims. It’s not about saying that Singh was correct in his criticism; it’s about his - or anyone else’s - right to test others’ claims in case they’re mistaken or misleading. It’s about the manifest injustice of the well-funded being able not only to refuse to play the scientific scrutiny game, but also to stop others playing it.
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 21:04, Reply)
The whole point of science is that your conclusions are open to scrutiny.
If you can't question people's findings, we might as well go back to the Dark Ages.
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 21:08, Reply)
without the bounce of debate we aren't going to get anywhere
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 21:15, Reply)
My thesis would be fucked by the precedent set bit this action.
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 21:17, Reply)
I'm currently seeing a chiropractor for back pain, and it's helped immensely. I wouldn't, however, go to a chiropractor to sort out asthma (or depression, which he said he could fix). I've stopped him doing neck manipulations, too, because I read Singh's article and it inspired me to do some research. Google "chiropractic stroke" and you'll see what I mean.
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 21:38, Reply)
What a bunch of numpties. Hopefully given the range and calibre of the listed signees some good will come of this.
(, Thu 4 Jun 2009, 22:09, Reply)
I was at the meeting in London where Simon Singh said he was - probably - going to appeal against the ruling on meaning. I got to talk to him, Dave Gorman, Nick Cohen and Prof Brian Cox - which was pretty damn cool - plus his lawyer, who had fled the clutches of the frankly evil libel lawyers Carter Ruck.
(, Sat 6 Jun 2009, 14:09, Reply)