often don't get what damage it would do to those who love them.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:05, Reply)
Whose feelings count most? (Don't have an answer, just curious.)
Isn't it just as selfish for a loved one to want someone to live against their wishes as it is for someone to kill themselves and hurt their loved ones?
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:08, Reply)
however (and speaking from a personal persepctive and experience) very often a person who is seriously contemplating it
is very often not in their 'usual' frame of mind to be making definitive wishes. Such behaviour associated with suicide may be
completely out of context with what is considered 'normal' behaviour for that person.
Therefore in such cases, is it selfish to try and save someone from themselves?
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:15, Reply)
just hypothesising - surely someone who has reasoned to the point of understanding that death would be the best thing, has gone through far more than anyone "left behind"
People get over it, life carries on for those still alive.
Now if you are simply talking about someone who off the cuff has said "i'm killing myself" then that's a completely different thing and they are childish idiots. Or probably drunk. In which case the people left behind are probably better off.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:12, Reply)
in that someone may have reasoned to the point of understanding that death would be the best thing.
very often this is not the case, it simply appears to be a simpler solution to an overall problem that the sufferer cannot rationally deal with.
In many cases little 'understanding' or conclusion is ever reached prior to deciding to act upon it.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:17, Reply)
I can assume the made up person thought everything through perfectly clearly after months of not being able to deal with something and finding friends and family and maybe even the samaritans unable to provide assitance.
Or you could assume that the made up person made a rash decision based on a film they saw which made it look really cool and dramatic and a way of "teaching them"
If it was me, maybe a dozen close friends would be upset, but they'd understand quite soon and get on with their own lives.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:27, Reply)
to realistically imagine being in a different mood to the one you are currently in, though, isn't it?
If you are happy, you feel as if you've always been happy (even if you are logically aware that is not the case).
If you are in a suicidal low, I'd guess it is almost impossible to think what it's like to be happy - which could easily lead to rash decisions.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:35, Reply)
what if you're happy, "sound of mind" and have simply weighed things up?
Aren't people entitled to do what they want with their own bodies?
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:42, Reply)
but given a random case on the internet (where this began) it's best to assume the more likely scenario is the other one, where they are in a low moment.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:46, Reply)
I can only offer hypothesis or my own opinion.
Personally I don't see why people cling to life so hard, or put such importance on it, its not like we have it for long. If there's nothing after this then every moment will be lost and rendered pointless, if there is something then there is not so much to worry about dying.
Living and reproducing is important for prolonging the species, but once you've done that, off you pop, you're not needed anymore (in the grand scheme of things)
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:56, Reply)
Perfectly valid as a reason not to save people who want to kill themselves, but it would also mean that you'd also have to believe that there's no-one in life worth saving, suicidal or not.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 18:52, Reply)
feel free to gaz me if you do want to punt concepts back and forth though
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 19:17, Reply)
who are happy and sound of mind will be suicidal, though.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 19:04, Reply)
How many people go to those for an 'escape' because they can see no other option to them. Then they regret it later or things turn around and they can get back from it and carry on 'normally'.
The death part just makes it really awkward to get back. So I don't anyone making a fully informed decision unless they're fealing with terminal illness etc.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:43, Reply)
you'd start a wave of depression running through all your youtube subscribers and ruin the idea of a smiley face on toast for ever more.
Is that what you want? Cosssssssss that's what'll 'appen!
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:35, Reply)
spesh since poons had a drink addiction .. and left lots of people behind ..
o well im off to be teetotal all fricking weekend - ffs
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:17, Reply)
If you're on a Euthanasia messageboard then you'd have a different discussion.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:20, Reply)
people who kill themselves are not in the right position to be able to reason such a thing.
They cannot imagine the low ever passing and so if the low will never pass it is 'reasonable' to kill yourself. However lows will almost always pass, even if that requires professional help.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:24, Reply)
the "right" position being... yours?
Who gets to say who is right?
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 17:39, Reply)
No one is always in the right frame of mind to make serious decisions, they go through times when they are and when they are not.
I'd say that someone who is suicidal is in the frame of mind when they are not able to rationalise efficiently.
So, the "right" position being... theirs when they are in a sound frame of mind.
(, Fri 19 Jun 2009, 18:40, Reply)