Are you a QOTWer? Do you want to start a thread that isn't a direct answer to the current QOTW? Then this place, gentle poster, is your friend.
(, Sun 1 Apr 2001, 1:00)
« Go Back | See The Full Thread
There was a famous psychological experiment done (and redone countless times with numerous variations), where they got members of the public and told them that, if they pushed a button, the person they can see in another room would be given a shock, which would increase in power until it proved fatal. Of course, the other person was an actor, and not actually shocked.
Some of the variations on the theme is them being rewarded for pushing the button, or told that the 'victim' was a serial killer etc.
Not all subjects pushed the button until the victim died, but apparently some did.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:43, 2 replies, latest was 16 years ago)
I'm not sure I see the relevance though.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:44, Reply)
Someone, who could be taken to be 'reasonable', is being successfully provoked into committing murder.
You could argue that by the subject showing the proclivity to murder, that they are not 'reasonable', but that's with the benefit of hindsight.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:46, Reply)
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:49, Reply)
a reason and a figure of authority to justify it
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:49, Reply)
It was about obedience, how far people will go following orders from a authority figure.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:47, Reply)
You could argue that following orders to kill is provocation, and thus fits the original question.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:48, Reply)
I wrongly assumed you could provoke someone else to do something to a third party, rather than provocation being a strict two-party affair (victim provoking assailant).
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:52, Reply)
but Wormulus is still right, they weren't provoked to kill, merely encouraged
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:53, Reply)
If there was a penalty for not going through with the task? (and assuming no prize for doing it)
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:54, Reply)
it might become coercion (though coercion is not a defense as it happens for murder) but it's still not provocation
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:56, Reply)
then you can offer a defence of duress to certain crimes. Not an unlawful killing though.
(, Tue 17 Aug 2010, 11:57, Reply)
« Go Back | See The Full Thread