b3ta.com qotw
You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » Question of the Week » Worst Band Ever » Post 1030428 | Search
This is a question Worst Band Ever

If I was in charge of the B3ta fatwa department, we wouldn't be hearing too much from Simply Red in the future. Who's on your musical shit list and why?

(, Thu 30 Dec 2010, 12:00)
Pages: Latest, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, ... 1

« Go Back

*deep breath* Nine Inch Nails
I've been putting off this confession ever since the QOTW went up but like a murderer wracked by guilt and unable to sleep at night, I need to get it off my chest. I CANNOT STAND NINE INCH NAILS AND TRENT REZNOR IS A COLOSSAL MUNCHKIN. There. There, I said it. *breathe*breathe*

He's just so damned clever and by God he makes sure you know it. He hammers it into you like Adam West fighting the Riddler. POW! He plays all those instruments himself you know! ZOT! He designed the logo himself too! KA-THWAP! Did you know he wrote 'Hurt' for Johnny Cash?

And his army of fans never stop either. Ohhh he's so EDGY and CHALLENGING and HE MADE INDUSTIAL MUSIC ACCESSIBLE TO THE MASSES.

Hey, Mr Reznor. You want to be edgy? How about confessing that you've said what little you had to say, you have nothing new, and you're going to shut up now FOREVER. Now, THAT would be maximum edgy. But you won't, will you?
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 15:26, 6 replies)
He wrote 'Hurt' for NIN, Johnny Cash just covered it
...I think
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 15:33, closed)

My fury has led me to phrase it badly. My point was that "Trent Reznor wrote 'Hurt', not Johnny Cash" is always being touted as trivia known only to a well-informed few, whilst in fact the entire bloody planet must know it by now.
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 15:50, closed)
No, the real secret is different
It's that the NIN version is better live than Cash's studio version (which is famous for being better than NIN's studio one).

You hate me too now, right?
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 16:16, closed)
I agree in part.
But I'm still a NIN fan as I love the effort he puts into his music, even if it does repeat the same samples a lot recently.
My favorite NIN though has always been his covers or other people's remixes of NIN tracks -- I think auteurs generally get a bit stifled and need other input.
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 17:32, closed)
without wanting to sound like the kind of arse being pilloried on this very QOTW for "it's so meaningful" type cobblers.......
....Hurt is about the most accurate description of what the human race are generally like in this day and age.
(, Wed 5 Jan 2011, 20:19, closed)
...
After The Perfect Drug everything has been shit. Loved them but they sound like a rock boyband now.

Shite songs like Starfuckers inc should not have been made.
(, Thu 6 Jan 2011, 13:16, closed)

« Go Back

Pages: Latest, 15, 14, 13, 12, 11, ... 1