For users who actually enjoy minimal, but not obligatory, conversation - I wanted to talk about books. I’ve been revisiting some old super-trashy novels I enjoyed in my twenties, but I’m getting different information out of them now I’m in my fifties. It’s quite interesting how lived experiences can change a lot of a story depending on when you read a thing. I suspect younger users may now find a plot twist in Roger Red Hat they never saw coming in primary school but, for the older gits amongst us, have you read something twice with many years in between and found it’s not how you remembered it? Otherwise tell me your favourite book, and why. I’m always happy to add more reading matter to my list. Hedge porn doesn’t count.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 6:28, Reply)
- it really depends on the mood, genre, etc. But I keep re-reading Lord of the Rings.
It's got a bit of everything. Reading as a teenager is totally different to reading it as a old git. Stuff that I would rush through before is now much more important to me.
Also, taking turns reading it out to each other was how Mrs Wizard and I came to routinely read aloud in the evenings - before being more conformist and vegging out in front of iPlayer.
alt: hobbit/goblin fic
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 6:48, Reply)
I haven’t ever read that, or seen the films. I have, over the past couple of years, started reading things that I wouldn’t choose for myself, so I’m taking that as a recommendation. Thank you! My brain has generally shunned fantasy-type novels but I shall have words with it and we will do the thing.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 6:52, Reply)
- and the Professor's love for Anglo-Saxon and North European poetry and epics and sagas is very much on display.
Be prepared for stylistic shifts (depending on who he imagined was telling you this bit of the story), and lots of long words in made up languages.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:24, Reply)
Genuinely serious about that, if I know what to expect it will be easier to not run away from!
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:28, Reply)
I do mine in a very strong Oirish accent. It's tons of fun.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:29, Reply)
I don’t think she thought it was fun at all. She was very nervous on arrival, so I just sat on the floor of the room I’d put her in, and read my book out loud so she’d get used to the fact I exist whether she likes it nor not.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:50, Reply)
I read Dune when I was 16 and then again about a year ago, and definitely got a different experience from it. The themes made a lot more sense as an adult, whereas when I was a teenager I didn’t really grasp that it’s not a hero’s story, it’s a morally grey story about difficult choices, utilitarianism and tripping balls.
However, my favourite book is Shogun, which I just finished re-reading for about the sixth or seventh time. It doesn’t really change on revisiting, but it’s long enough that every time I go back to it there’s a bit I'd completely forgotten.
Or hedge porn, lol.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:40, Reply)
Dune sounds right up my street. Never even heard of Shogun so I’ll look it up after I’ve had a bath.
If you like Dune (and I’m only going on what you just said about it) you may like Doris Lessing - Memoirs of a Survivor.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:45, Reply)
I have a few books I want to get through but I can definitely add some dystopian feminist sci-fi to my backlog, thanks.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:53, Reply)
I’m not even sure why. It’s a well-written fish-out-of-water tale set in Japan in 1600. An English guy ends up there by accident and gets drawn into the politics of the imminent war. It has themes of death, deceit and self-reflection. And it has samurai and ninjas, which are cool.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 7:47, Reply)
I’m actually working through Gai-Jin for the first time at the moment. It’s ok. I’ve read Tai-Pan, Noble House and King Rat. That only leaves Whirlwind. Have you?
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:17, Reply)
Not sure it’s definitely my kind of thing but I don’t know until I make the effort.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:05, Reply)
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:30, Reply)
It reminded me of this, entirely unrelated and just took me a bloody long time to hunt down because I couldn’t remember the title, or author. Because I have a goldfish brain. amzn.eu/d/05ZcYENd
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:55, Reply)
www.amazon.co.uk/Salt-World-History-Kurlansky-2003-03-06/dp/B0182Q3JNS/?th=1
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:42, Reply)
And milk, apparently. amzn.eu/d/08soIth3
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:51, Reply)
I knew Shogun was very loosely based on a true story, and that appears to be it.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:57, Reply)
it's a great read, especially for a Shogun fan. Love the Richard Chamberlain TV adaptation too. It was the most expensive tv programme ever made at the time. The 'making of' extras in the DVD box set are insane. Plus it's got Toshiro Mifune in it, as well as Pigsy from Monkey.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:42, Reply)
The Richard Chamberlain TV version was great, and so was the recent one (last year or whenever).
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 12:13, Reply)
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 13:14, Reply)
I read it when I was 19, just left home to move to a big city to go to college and it was the most shocking thing I'd read. It was tough going, getting through the changes of voice, the dialects, and it's visceral and grim but the characters and situations were totally engrossing. I was having a tough time with things, but looking up from the pages of the book, I could not stop reading; I just looked around and kept thinking how lucky I was. I've never gone back and re-read it, but that book's up there with Reservoir Dogs in the cinema and The Bends and Never Mind being released as iconic cultural events of my youth.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:03, Reply)
I was very unshocked by it, but I’d been surrounded by people of that very lifestyle for a bit which was enough to make me certainly feel very lucky and not end up like that. I had a very different background, though, when you know people’s stories it’s hard to see how they wouldn’t end up like it, and I felt like I was waiting for that to show up in Trainspotting, and it never quite did for me. It doesn’t take away from it being a very well observed “in the now” book, though. I hope that makes sense. I am very very tired.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:10, Reply)
I have to imagine because of course I haven't fucking read it.
Keep meaning to go back to Nineteen Eighty-Four, I'm sure it would be more terrifying now. When I first read it, the idea of your TV watching/listening to you seemed impossibly fanciful.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:12, Reply)
I think I read Nineteen Eighty-Four when I was twelve or thirteen so it’d be hugely interesting to read it again. Good call.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 8:21, Reply)
Quite upset me at the time, I don't suppose it's any easier reading it now, given how things have developed.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 13:10, Reply)
Worse combo would be taking acid and considering determinism. Not that I have. Well, not at the same time.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 17:35, Reply)
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:45, Reply)
Hurrah for Google, I shall go and see how dull these people are.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:08, Reply)
He wrote The Man Who Fell To Earth too, which I didn't really enjoy.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 13:05, Reply)
Went from there to a brief stint reading Enid Blyton, then onto Stephen King. I discovered the books of Sven Hassell when I was in my early teens and absolutely loved them. Then came Terry Prattchett. I've got every Discworld book except the last one. As for my favourite book, that's a tough one. I'd say it's a tie between Pratchett's Thud and Benchley's Jaws.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 10:53, Reply)
Love a bit of Stephen King, Insomnia and Rose Madder are two favourites.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:07, Reply)
I loved the earlier ones, like Carrie, Salem's Lot, Christine and the like.
Faraway Tree I found mildly irritating, because I knew I would never know what Silky's biscuits tasted like.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 11:19, Reply)
It's a really well crafted story about relationships dressed up as a hip 90's pop culture novel.
It has been interesting to see how my relationship to the culture of the time has shifted over the years and how it still has the power to fuck me up.
(, Tue 17 Nov 2026, 13:52, Reply)