and being able to say you're not even aware of it is doubly so, though cave isn't so big that it's not inconceivable that jonbob has somehow overlooked him.
I thought the interesting part was about the AI writing songs, but letting everyone know you think he sucks is fascinating information
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:23, Reply)
OH NO, JONBOB OFF OF THE INTERNET HAS NEVER HEARD OF HIM - HE MUST BE SHIT THEN!
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:25, Reply)
red right hand
all of murder ballads
just to get started
probably one of the most accomplished musicians in history, i reckon
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:38, Reply)
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:41, Reply)
I just find it amusing that a man ostensibly as well-known as he is, with a career spanning more than my entire life has had such an impact on the culture of the English-speaking world that I’ve no idea who he is. I have heard Red Right Hand but had to read his discography before I knew it was anything to do with him. Perhaps it’s the excessively fawning tone that Guardian writers are wont to use is what gets my back up.
The fact that his lyrical output is apparently almost indistinguishable from ELIZA’s great-great-grandchild is just icing on the cake. I’m more into instrumental music; seems odd that AI composers haven’t made as much impact as in the visual arts.
Ed: by way of contrast I think Christopher Tin is a fucking genius.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:46, Reply)
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 9:51, Reply)
I once tried to listen to one of his albums. Once.
Remember the craze for serial killer biographies in the 80s? Most people moved on. Nick Cave couldn't, obviously, and so we suffer his deeply cringeworthy obsession through the medium of his terrible, bland music.
He can't sing. That is, he probably can sing a bit as a tenor, but insists to himself that he's a baritone or bass. He can't hit the right notes because they are out of his vocal range. As a professional recording artist it is inconceivable that he's not heard his own voice played back, he must be aware of this on some level...
But he's obviously pretentious and deluded. His song writing is shit and mostly unmemorable. 'Red Right Hand' is only memorable for the 6 seconds played in a Hellboy movie (the worst 6 seconds of that movie, by the way). 'Wild Rose' is only memorable because that's the Kylie Minogue song where she duets with the guy who can't sing. He has no other hits.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 14:26, Reply)
1 - the song is called 'Where the Wild Roses Grow', not 'Wild Rose';
2 - shall I put you down as a 'maybe'?
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 14:51, Reply)
1 - his 'serial killer' obsession was pretty much over by the second half of the nineties, after Murder Ballads in 1996 he was pretty much done with the subject;
2 - who really gives a shit about his singing voice? Plenty of singer/songwriters have awful voices (Bob Dylan, Tom Waits, Leonard Cohen etc), what makes them great is the delivery and the strength of the songs themselves.
3 - 'hits'? are you genuinely trying to make the case that the artistic/creative quality of a musician's work is directly measurable by sales/profits earned? Because that's clearly risible bollocks.
I reckon you should maybe go and have a listen to The Boatman's Call or something.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 14:55, Reply)
1: That was probably the album I tried to listen to.
2: Me. If he had a talent for singing it might offset his terrible songwriting. Comparing him to those giants is just outrageous.
3: No, those are the two songs of his that I can actually remember.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 17:06, Reply)
b3ta.com/links/1598744
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 17:56, Reply)
It had Steve Railsback driving with the music playing?
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 15:36, Reply)
The last three Bad Seeds albums are magnificent works. Ghosteen in particular is devastatingly beautiful.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 18:00, Reply)
I reckon he peaked with Boatman's Call.
Happy family life fucking ruined his songs.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 18:29, Reply)
You could make that argument, but then you’d be suggesting that O Children wasn’t one of his finer works.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 20:41, Reply)
if you've had your head in modern instrumental composition you might not have looked up much to notice other genres. I'm sure there's reams of r&b and hiphop acts of the last 10 years I've no fucking clue about.
Anyway, I was more reacting to a trend of people canning others posts, like the seinfeld animation below. if someones posted something they like, saying it sucks is not really in the spirit. perhaps it's a sign of depressing times
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 10:14, Reply)
People are generally quicker to publicly complain than to compliment.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 10:21, Reply)
If your only experience of Nick Cave's musical output has been 'Red Right Hand', then I suspect that's what has happened.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 10:34, Reply)
I was merely observing that he’s a walking, talking Klein bottle.
(, Wed 18 Jan 2023, 11:01, Reply)