You are not logged in. Login or Signup
Home » links » Link 1601417 | Random (Thread)

This is a normal post Fucking fair play to Lineker.
Far too many of these public figures pandering to criticism the moment they say something mildly controversial.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 11:08, Reply)
This is a normal post Fair play to him indeed
He’s showing just how little dissent this government will tolerate. They’ve brought an enormous amount of pressure on to the supposedly impartial BBC in order to silence criticism. Rather than stand up for freedom of speech they’ve folded in no time at all.

Ironically, it was exactly this kind of behaviour that was warned about when Johnson appointed a political ally to chair the BBC…
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 13:36, Reply)
This is a normal post The way I see it, the BBC have completely fucked the dog.
If Lineker had made his feelings known during broadcast in his capacity as an employee of the BBC, i could understand them suspending him. Whether or not you believe the BBC *is* genuine in its pursuit of impartiality, impartial media is massively important - particularly in the days of social media brigading and left/right leaning media outlets becoming increasingly hardline.
That being said, he didn't make the comments during broadcast. He made them on his personal Twitter account. And regardless of what part of the political spectrum his comment fell on, they were his comments, not those of the BBC and considering that the comment broke no laws (for now, at least), he hasn't exactly brought his employers into disrepute by making them.

Of course, we all know that the BBC isn't genuine in its pursuit of impartiality. They're absolutely shit scared of upsetting whatever party is currently in charge and will quite obviously lean towards whatever narrative the current government is spewing out, regardless of that party's ideological stance.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 14:39, Reply)
This is a normal post He wasn’t impartial in his broadcast opening remarks about the hosts of last year’s World Cup.
Mercifully, the BBC kept mum, and he soon got into the spirit of things.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 15:07, Reply)
This is a normal post No, those were scripted comments, during the World Cup
This exact point was raised on the Today Programme on Radio 4. The BBC wanted to point out the issues with Qatar while also covering it.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 15:34, Reply)
This is a normal post Who wrote that script? I want names.

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 20:20, Reply)
This is a normal post Dunno - but here's a link to the discussion with an expert
- stat's at 1 hour 13 minutes (assuming you haven't had enough of experts, of course).

www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m001jsrz
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 11:26, Reply)
This is a normal post You won’t believe it when you hear what the experts at Independent SAGE are projecting for the imminent avian flu!

(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:26, Reply)
This is a normal post I don't recall the BBC ever being this afraid of Labour.
But then, Labour wasn't constantly threatening to scrap the TV license.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 15:32, Reply)
This is a normal post Gagging the BBC started with New Labour under Blair
- during the Iraq dossier investigation, and that so called suicide.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 15:36, Reply)
This is a normal post Not that I'm saying "They're as bad as each other" or anything

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 15:37, Reply)
This is a normal post They aren't, and you're wrong about BBC gagging starting under Blair.
www.youtube.com/watch?v=mH2T7N35rVA
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 16:00, Reply)
This is a normal post Fairy nuff, 'twas ever thus and all that
I just remember a drastic pulling of the Beebs journalistic teeth at that time.

The crappy attempts to "show both sides" by letting rabid swivel eyes loons on as pundits next to actual experts on a topic seemed to ramp up around that time, and has been the bane of TV debate ever since.

Probably didn't start there, of course.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 16:15, Reply)
This is a normal post There was an awful lot of censorship during WW2 and the cold war
and I believe the government retained most of the mechanisms for gagging in the interests of national security as well as the nebulous public interest.

The BBC was fairly critical of the Blair and Brown era governments. It didn't act as a propaganda wing of the Labour Party. Andrew fucking Neal was the face of BBC political shows, for example.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 16:53, Reply)
This is a normal post You seem to be arguing with me about something?
Or am I mistaking your tone?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 17:56, Reply)
This is a normal post Don't worry about my tone.

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 19:03, Reply)
This is a normal post that hutton fallout had other repercussions, IW, that got swept under the rug
with dyke resigning and the board being neutered, they established a BBC Trust stacked with private industry grandees and led by a conservative (when brown lost it got really stacked with tories)
They had a project called the Digital Curriculum, later renamed the BBC Jam. It had spent 175 million pound of taxpayers money with additional funds from the Dept Trade & Industry. It was to make really high quality (175m is a far chunk of change) online learning available free to all british schoolchildren 6 - 16 based on the national curriculum, and to stimulate industry, 50% was done in-house and 50% by commercial developers. 1 month after going live those same companies that had been taking the money complained in the European Competition Competition that it was unfair government subsidy that was going stop schools buying their crappy cheap elearning. Even though the advice was that it was a meritless case, as it's there in the BBC charter to provide education to children. Within a few months of being formed, the Trust decided to not even hear or contest the complaint, but killed off the project. 250 job losses, 175 million wasted, and none of it could be shown again. it didn't even make the papers because there was all this other shit going down, blair resigning etc.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 22:09, Reply)
This is a normal post I'd rather they kept the TV Licence going than have it stuck onto general taxation,
why should I pay for something I don't use?
Although, happy to chuck the Beeb a tenner each year for use of their radio stations and news site.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 20:32, Reply)
This is a normal post
Shall we stop funding kidderminster library too, because Turtle Power has never visited it? Start charging entrance fees for all parks? Get rid of the NHS, why should I pay for someone else's cancer treatment?
Just curious if your BBC user-pays stance extends to other things that are paid for collectively?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 21:47, Reply)
This is a normal post No, because the other things you mentioned are worth having.

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 22:00, Reply)
This is a normal post that's a different argument
whether you think some things are collectively worth funding or not.
it's more that when you have the idea that it should be optional to individually fund some things on the basis that if you like or use them, you end up getting what we had in feudal times, where anything good is the preserve of the wealthy. I see this argument a lot when it comes to the licence fee, but not for other things, like funding childcare when you don't have kids.
Anyway, I agree with you that the licence fee is increasing anachronistic as we move to devices, but there's a danger of even less independence once it's paid for directly from government
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 22:52, Reply)
This is a normal post Much of my issue with the Licence is, I object to an intimidation-based enforcement,
where you are presumed guilty for not buying an entirely voluntary subscription. Visits from guys trying to fool you that they have grounds to enter, and monthly envelopes through the door printed with titles like "Investigation opened" or "Reference: your day in court". It isn't (yet) a legal requirement to watch the closest thing the UK has to state television programming.

Not sure what I would suggest instead to deal with the actual fee dodgers who use a TV or iPlayer. Of course adding into a general tax would resolve it instantly. "You've paid for it, might as well use it."
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 23:47, Reply)
This is a normal post Yeah cos corporate news channels are so great
Fox anyone? Have you watched any US news channels? Wake up.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 4:55, Reply)
This is a normal post
How does that counter his point about not liking the heavy-handed enforcement of the licence fee?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 11:33, Reply)
This is a normal post "BBC > ITV, therefore Capita are beyond reproach."
Also, supposedly any address without a licence, they monitor your internet data packets in case you decide to use a service they can pounce on you for. Nothing dodgy about that whatsoever.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 21:54, Reply)
This is a normal post Not exactly.
You need to be logged into a registered BBC account in order to access iPlayer/Sounds. They can check the logs on your account to see which device on which WAN IP initiated the connection, but the most they'll gather from that is which service provider you're using.
Of course, the BBC could ask the service provider to divulge whether or not the connected address has a licence or not, but I very much suspect that in the vast majority of cases, the ISP will politely tell the BBC to get fucked.
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 8:18, Reply)
This is a normal post I suspect the procedure has changed over the last few years, anyway
www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2016/aug/14/bbc-licence-fee-iplayer-surveillance
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 23:51, Reply)
This is a normal post Taking the BBC element to one side
Where are you with the whole Conservatives shutting down dissent thing?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 17:20, Reply)
This is a normal post It's not really the Conservatives though, is it?
It's the BBC trying to avoid upsetting the Conservatives and making an absolute cock up in the process. If they had just kept their mouth shut, Lineker's tweet wouldn't have had nearly the amount of exposure it has ended up having and the gov could have largely brushed their embarrasingly half-arsed 'stop the boats' plan under the rug. Now they've actually got to put some real work into justifying it and coming up with some kind of workable proof of concept.
Lineker is the only one coming out of this looking good, and that's fine by me.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 18:01, Reply)
This is a normal post
do you really think it's surprising that the BBC want to appease the conservatives, because of the sheer amount of right wing people appointed to the BBC over a decade?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 18:43, Reply)
This is a normal post Not at all.

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 18:49, Reply)
This is a normal post
so Gary Lineker as the next PM then?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 19:39, Reply)
This is a normal post Well, he certainly seems to have more integrity than the last few.

(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 19:43, Reply)
This is a normal post Isn't it?
Only there don't half appear to have been a lot of Conservative MPs crawling out from under their rocks to criticise Lineker over the last few days.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 20:39, Reply)
This is a normal post Well, quite right.
I applaud his steadfast refusal to backpedal on his comment. But he still invoked Godwin's law which kinda removes any credence from his argument. Especially since the comparison to nazi Germany is both lazy and inaccurate.
Braverman's plan is fucking shit. It's a load of half-arsed shitbollocks full of holes and inconsistencies. But it doesn't detract from the fact that we do need a more efficient and effective immigration and asylum system. Automatically punishing every single person that lands in the UK via dinghy/lorry/container by automatically blacklisting them and trebucheting them back over the channel ain't it.
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 22:01, Reply)
This is a normal post It's not a Godwin, and it is accurate.
Lineker said the language used is reminiscent of 1930s Germany. The exact same point was made by holocaust survivor Joan Salter: www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-64282961

Dehumanising language has utterly predictable consequences which we are currently living through. Have you forgotten the firebomb attack on the refugee centre? The violent protests outside home office requisitioned hotels?
(, Sat 11 Mar 2023, 23:08, Reply)
This is a normal post
That's some mighty fine hairsplitting you're doing there. Nobody was in any doubt what he was referring to even if he didn't name them.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 11:35, Reply)
This is a normal post What hair am I splitting? Who is the 'he' you are referring to?
Did you post this in the right place? Doesn't seem to make any sense.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 14:37, Reply)
This is a normal post OH wait I think I get it:
you think I'm saying it's not a Godwin because he didn't use the actual word Nazi. That's not what I'm saying at all.

Godwin himself pointed out that the law doesn't apply when the thing you are comparing to Nazis is literally comparable to Nazis. The language used by this government is literally directly comparable to the language used by the Nazis to justify the murder of millions of people, as holocaust survivor Joan Salter points out.

Sorry if this point isn't immediately obvious to everyone, but it should be.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 14:48, Reply)
This is a normal post Is it, though? Is Suella Braverman really trying to justify the murder of millions of people when she uses the term 'Invasion'? Is she advocating ethnic cleansing?
Was Walter Cronkite also channeling Hitler when he referred to the massive surge in popularity of British musical acts as an invasion during the '60s? That's essentially what you're saying.

I should add that I don't particularly like the term 'invasion' in regards to the numbers of refugees/immigrants trying to enter the UK via unofficial channels. It feels deliberately sensationalist. The kind of shit you'd see plastered on the front page of The Sun. But you can't pick and choose which 'invasions' are Nazi and which ones are nice. Not without pulling a Godwin.

Your (and other overly flappy Leftists) approach seems to be "tOriEs ArE aS bAd As HiTlEr BeCaUsE sHe SaId InVaSiOn' which, I'm terribly sorry to inform you, is peak Godwinism.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 15:17, Reply)
This is a normal post The language is the same as that used in the 1930s that set the tone for everything that followed.
Enemies of the people. Traitors. Lefty lawyers. Invasion. Swarm. Illegals.

The consequences of this kind of language is predictable, we are living through those consequences now. E.g. the acts of violence and terrorism directed against refugees I mentioned before.

Invoking Godwin's law over this stuff is simply wrong. Your characterisation of my argument is simply wrong. Is Joan Salter a flappy leftist?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 15:58, Reply)
This is a normal post What makes Joan Salter the foremost word on the subject?
Because she managed to avoid dying during the Holocaust? By escaping France? When she was about three? I'm very happy for her and stuff, but surviving a nasty bicycle accident at 5 years old doesn't make me a stunt man, even if I don't stop talking about the incident for the remainder of my natural life.

It's Godwinism. Get over it.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 16:08, Reply)
This is a normal post Well, it's everyone's loss
to have ignored my post below and had this 24 hour argument instead.

We could all have gone down a fun Automata UK rabbit hole, and ended up having a classic Spectrum vs C64 scrap.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 16:38, Reply)
This is a normal post Spectrum.

(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 16:51, Reply)
This is a normal post Acorn Electron,
you donkey-raping geronto-necro-paedo-KFC-United-loving father-fucker!
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 20:19, Reply)
This is a normal post c64 with tape drive ftw

(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 21:43, Reply)
This is a normal post The correct answer
is C64 music and Spectrum graphics.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 21:48, Reply)
This is a normal post You're half right.

(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 22:03, Reply)
This is a normal post Screechy Spectrum music
and low saturation C64 graphics?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 22:07, Reply)
This is a normal post Speccy graphics are inferior.
If you're judging based on C64 ports of Speccy games and vice versa, the original usually looks better. If you're judging based on arcade ports, the C64 usually looks better (I say usually, but I can't think of an exception). I'm occasionally still amazed by C64 demos. If you're judging based purely on vectors, maybe the Speccy wins. If you're judging on literally anything else to do with graphics, resolution, frame rate, scrolling, sprites, colours, etc., the C64 wins.

There's a stylistic uniformity to Speccy games. I can understand the nostalgia for it, but I never thought it looked good at the time.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 23:29, Reply)
This is a normal post I'm judging on nostalgia aesthetics.
The C64 wasn't as pixelly, and not as brightly coloured. It looked better at the time for the reasons you mention, but now looks quite bland - you still get indie games looking like that. The Spectrum's limitations and quirks means it takes you straight back to the 80s.
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 0:11, Reply)
This is a normal post as a c64 family, I pitied the spectrum users
most of the spectrum games were ported to c64, but less the other way. And they just looked better on the commodore. the vic 20 was an abomination, though.
a few years ago when I went on a nostalgic look back, they had dated and I preferred the DOS version, something I never saw at the time because no one had an early ibm in my suburb
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 23:40, Reply)
This is a normal post You dismissed the Nazi comparison as flappy leftism. Is Joan Salter a flappy leftist?
You see, she makes the same reality-based argument as Lineker. Many holocaust survivors have been recorded making very similar arguments.

How is a bike accident comparable to having ones family murdered by the state? Are you okay?

You're simply refusing to understand what Godwin's law is, despite being told. You are making arguments from wilful ignorance.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:27, Reply)
This is a normal post Her family wasn't murdered by the state.
Your argument is starting to fall apart, lad. Don't embarrass yourself by doubling down in it.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:37, Reply)
This is a normal post Holocaust denial now is it?
Are you okay?

Is Joan Salter a flappy leftist?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:54, Reply)
This is a normal post Not as flappy as you, mate. Although, based on the recent viral video of her being particularly flappy and unrehearsed, I'd assume so
Her parents relocated to the UK, by the way. Of course, now you're probably going to claim your were referring to her extended family being murdered. Because you just can't take a loss gracefully, can you? Bit sad, mate.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 18:18, Reply)
This is a normal post Deeply depressing, because my whole argument rested very specifically on her immediate family being murdered by the state. This renders all my arguments entirely wrong. Damn.
I hope you're just trolling. You are not making valid arguments. I think you just want to provoke a certain obvious response to your performative cruelty. It's really very sad in the most literal sense of the word. Shameful, too.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 19:02, Reply)
This is a normal post
Are you claiming that personal tweets shouldn't affect employment?
Like, if I work at McDonald's and tweet that their burgers are shite,
Or if I work for Borders & Enforcement, and privately support BNP?
Or if I'm a policeman who creates a website of where illegal drugs can be bought?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 16:59, Reply)
This is a normal post
so you're arguing that anyone who gets 1 penny of tax payers money should not have the ability to say anything negative about the goverment?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:22, Reply)
This is a normal post
No, strawman.
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 19:16, Reply)
This is a normal post He wasn't criticising the BBC. He was criticising the government.
Still a bit fuzzy headed from last night?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 17:34, Reply)
This is a normal post
I didn't say he was.
Still a bit fuzzy headed from being a dick?
(, Sun 12 Mar 2023, 19:18, Reply)
This is a normal post You likened his criticism of the Government to a McDonalds employee criticising McDonalds food.
It's nothing like that. It's like a McDonalds employee getting fired for saying that the security guard employed by the shopping centre that the McDonalds is located in is thick as shit.
(, Mon 13 Mar 2023, 8:48, Reply)