Ian Tomlinson was the man who died whilst walking home during the G20 demonstrations. He was not a protestor.
The police initially said there had been no contact with him prior to his death.
After watching this, I don't think I believe them.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 19:47, Reply)
That's quite something and a real shame that it ended up like this!
I was there for most of the day and spent a lot of it skirting around the front lines talking to both sides, on the whole most people were peacefully going about the day, Both police and protesters, I got shoved about a few times by the riot guys but I was down the front getting shots and fully expected to get nudged a few times.
I know the spot that fountain is and it was a good couple of streets away from any real trouble! Utterly uncalled for, I don;t have sound on this PC but unless he said something Very very bad then that guy has done the force no favours at all with their image!
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 19:55, Reply)
doesn't really let us know if anything was said by either side. After the bloke goes down, someone shouts 'what are you doing?' .The voice-over claims/states that the guy was just walking home from work.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:02, Reply)
what the police can get away with these days (though i don't sympathise with the protesters in this case). And the scariest thing is that the guy filming the police in this video AND the photographer who you see can be charged for photographing the police. Isn't this video proof of why we SHOULD allow photography of the police?
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 19:58, Reply)
"It's illegal to photograph the police" thing was just blown out of proportion? As in, they can stop people from filming if they suspect it's for terrorist purposes, but they can't charge someone for just filming something they don't want people to see.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:15, Reply)
there just haven't been any high profile cases yet. Most people will just back down when the police ask them not to take a photo of something.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:19, Reply)
Absolutely this......Take the law as stated, and then apply it to anything.
"We were performing a street-level testicular-pressure interrogation when we saw someone filming us. We were pretty sure that he was a terrorist, so we took his camera, beat the fuck out of him and charged him".
Basically, if the police don't act with the highest of professional conduct, then they are no longer police, they are a gang.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:26, Reply)
but most people would just back down anyway, so it's not obvious that there's any difference. The police couldn't stop you filming before, and they can't now. But, even before the law came in, I'm willing to bet that they tried a few times, and met with success.
And, frankly, if a big guy in a helmet with a stick asks me to do something, I'm likely to go along with that request. I'll kick myself later - but it'll be much too late by then. Esprit d'escalier and all that...
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:30, Reply)
The story is leaked to the papers, in this case that nobody will be able to take photos of police, massive outcry etc.
Then a few days later it turns out that there are all kinds of 'if's and 'but's on the actual legislation. The people who oppose the law realise they now look hysterical and shut up about it for a while. The watered down version which would have been opposed passes through with less trouble.
In a few months, perhaps, the first prosecution goes ahead, there's a bit of a fuss about it, then people move on. The second prosecution doesn't even get into the papers.
It's no great conspiracy theory, the people in charge right now (including much of the press, the opposition, etc) have quite authoritarian ideas and know how to put them into action. It's a proven vote winner. Scare people and offer them 'law & order', whatever that means.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:49, Reply)
Just because people don't challenge the police about their rights doesn't make it legal.
www.sirimo.co.uk/media/UKPhotographersRights.pdf
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 22:09, Reply)
seems a bit rough of the cops, in the wrong place at the wrong time I guess given he was apparently just walking home. Shame he was also apparently quite pissed so might not have been able to explain he wasn't anything to do with the protest coherently. I don't think it's an avenue to go down of 'Police brutality' with sound bytes, given from the knock I see indicates his personal health would be more called in question and to blame.
Then you have the highly charged and emotional atmosphere of the moment, experienced by the police as well (given they are as human as protesters). Having bottles hurled at you is generally going to be quite emotional.
I'm sad the bloke died, and it is only appropriate it will be investigated.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:00, Reply)
they are human? Doesn't matter. The people protesting are a massive collective of politically aware people and dreadlocked fuckwits. They are there for a number of reasons...
..the police SHOULD be there to maintain order and make our citizens feel safe. They have a RESPONSIBILITY to act correctly. Mainly because it's their fucking job.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:06, Reply)
The copper obviously shoved him over without any fucking provocation, the bloke just seemed to be dawdling along trying to avoid all the jack-booted cunts behind him. If you push someone over and they die of a heart-attack then a murder/manslaughter charge will be filed against you. Don't appologise for this sort of behaviour or rationalise it, it's a violent copper who enjoys pushing people around because he can....
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:27, Reply)
He was actually in the way. If you see a police line like that it's common sense to move away, becauswe that's what a police line is for.
I wouldn't be surprised if one of the officers told him to move and he wasn't listening/ couldn't here.
In the end I think this is more likely to be an unfortunate accident than Police brutality.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:34, Reply)
why could they not just move slightly to the side to pass by old wobbly guy with a beer in him?
no, fuck that, he looks nothing like a protester and he is alone-just push him to the floor.
since when has walking down the street been a crime?
since when have the police used unprovoked assault as a policing tool?
the guy should face a charge of manslaughter,nothing less. the fact that the police tried to cover this up speaks volumes, but it will happen again.
tragic and avoidable.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 23:19, Reply)
I didn't think I was apologizing for this, but given that rant you seem to have your mind already made up
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:51, Reply)
I just wish the stupid fuckers would at least get their story straight.
It's no wonder people don't trust them.
It's also interesting to see that the behaviour of the Met hasn't changed much in the 20 years since I first became "acquainted" with them outside the South African embassy.
edit: where does it say he was pissed? and does that make it okay to assault somebody? Don't believe everything you read in the media.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 22:05, Reply)
though I read it in the Independent this morning
Though from the footage, it seems quite obvious; but away with 'does that make it okay to assault somebody' type of comment; simply assess the scenario
What next, confront and contain a bunch of angry anarchist tossers with polite warnings or harsh language from venting their fury? As I said, it's terrible the bloke is dead, but that bunch of left wing wankers don't exactly protest peacefully do they?
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 22:36, Reply)
is not to sink to their level. They have to maintain their calm, they have to act professionally, and they cannot knock a man to the ground without provocation. Tensions were high, there was violence - it doesn't matter. It is the police's job to behave to a certain level, and here, they clearly did not.
(, Wed 8 Apr 2009, 0:49, Reply)
I hope this shows all the papers in London that their "violent hooligans vs professional, disciplined police" angle on the whole thing is a fucking crock of shit.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:09, Reply)
For once, me and you are on the same wavelength....
edit for grammar police: For once, you and I are on the same wavelength.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:28, Reply)
I'm an English teacher and linguistics researcher and I never correct anyone's grammar these days. Firstly because most of the rules are little more than nonsense made up by pedants, and secondly because if I'm "correcting" something I expect to get paid.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 21:10, Reply)
By throwing in a sane comment like this, you've confused me. I soooooo want to disagree with you.
*loses faith*
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 20:38, Reply)
Just because you don't think anything will be done about something doesn't mean it doesn't matter.
To think otherwise is to say "Do what you like. Not my problem." I, for one, don't want to go down that route.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 22:12, Reply)
It's my standard Dekion strategy. Whatever he posts, I automatically want to kick to death. When he posts something sane, I get all confused.
(, Tue 7 Apr 2009, 22:15, Reply)